When I sat down to write Ghostlighting (GL), I neither knew of the extraordinary success of The Woman in Black (TWIB) nor had I read or seen it. When I did find out about it, I avoided exposure to it so it wouldn’t influence me. Though I had no idea how difficult it would be, I wanted to grow an original flower in a well-ploughed field (and I still ended up echoing Henry James and Shirley Jackson).

On our recent trip to Ireland and the UK, we saw TWIB at Dublin’s Gaiety Theatre. It was brilliant and we had a wonderful time. Afterwards, for reasons that will become apparent, we celebrated in a bar around the corner from the theatre. Thank you, Hennessy.
Afterwards, I jotted down a few thoughts about the plays—specifically, where and why I liked one play over the other.
Note: There may be the slightest possibility that I could I could be a teeeentsy bit biased in my perceptions.
GHOSTLIGHTING
Though both plays use meta elements, GL revolves around a writer and a director, rather than around a writer and an actor, yet all the characters are integral to GL, as is the theatre itself.
Though it may have been the production or because I was distracted by analyzing things, the ending of TWIB seems slightly muddled and the theatrical framework only really serves the final line (though it does so extremely well).
GL screws more with the audiences’ minds, I think, making their environment part of the story and upping their anxiety. That is, GL is more immersive. (Still, at TWIB, they had to help an elderly woman outside at the interval because she fainted.)
Excepting for the opening and closing framework, TWIB is a period piece. GL has period elements, but is contemporary.
People leave TWIB laughing and chattering; people leave GL murmuring and looking over their shoulders.
GL doesn’t milk the audience by implying the endangerment of children or animals.
GL has a cast of four women and two men, though it’s built so productions can play with gender. TWIB primarily has a cast of two men. The only main female character in TWIB is vindictive and malevolent.
Both plays have their humor, but, to my ear, GL is funnier. In TWIB, some people laughed at the haunting moments (probably from releasing tension). This did not happen in GL. More often, they gasped.
GL draws upon a multitude of “true accounts” as I want those in the paranormal community to go, yeah, that feels right. I doubt that was a concern for the authors of TWIB.
Both plays are about haunted houses, but, in GL, “house” has multiple meanings.
THE WOMAN IN BLACK
The fog effect is fantastic!
Requires less tech (though the sets are equally complex).
Uses fewer actors.
The play ran for 27 years on London’s West End, making it the second-longest running play in West End history.
Apparently, there’s an audience for ghost stories or something.



